An Examination of Fascist Ideas in India and in Nazi Germany

Luna Sabastian’s book Fascism in India: Race, Caste, and Hindutva provides important insights into the complex history of a transnational ideology whose legacy continues to haunt India, Germany and the world.

Illustration: Pariplab Chakraborty
India is currently ruled by an authoritarian prime minister from the right-wing Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which espouses a brand of politicised Hinduism or Hindutva. The founding ideologues of Hindu nationalism admired certain elements of Italian Fascism and German National Socialism, as various scholars have noted. Historical scholarship has also examined the asymmetrical transfer of Fascist/Nazi ideologemes from European metropoles to colonial India as well as interpersonal contacts.
Luna Sabastian’s book Fascism in India: Race, Caste, and Hindutva (Harvard University Press, September 2025) takes a refreshingly novel approach. It reframes India “as genuinely generative of fascist ideas”, particularly from the 1920s to the 1960s, i.e. approximately encompassing two decades before and after India’s decolonization in 1947.PlayNextMute
The introduction makes the justified claim that the book makes four major contributions to the field of global intellectual history, namely, (1) demonstrating how fascism’s Indian contemporaries can advance its understanding (2) rethinking the meaning of race and sovereign territory – blood and soil from an Indian vantage point (3) discussing caste (Kaste in German) under the Nazis, i.e., the ability of India to contribute a universal concept to modern political grammar (4) highlighting two distinct forms of Hindutva which compete today.
Illustration: Pariplab Chakraborty.
These four themes have been discussed over five chapters. The first chapter concentrates on three Indian (Bengali) protagonists who could observe fascism first-hand and provide their own interpretations of it: Benoy Kumar Sarkar, M. N. Roy and Subhas Chandra Bose. While Sarkar and Bose saw fascism as an extreme form of nationalism which they approved of, M. N. Roy, the itinerant communist turned humanist, understandably found fascism to be reactionary. This chapter provides an interesting synopsis of Subhas Bose’s political ideal, which awkwardly combined aspects of fascism and socialism but rejected “Moscow-style Communism” since it was allegedly incompatible with Indian nationalism.
One caveat here is that Bose’s collaboration with Nazi Germany took its inspiration not only from the Ghadr movement, as Sabastian claims, but also from radical anti-colonialists like Virendranath Chattopadhyaya, who took a leading role in the Berlin-based India Independence Committee during the First World War, a connection that has been duly noted.
Benoy Kumar Sarkar is a central figure in this book. Different aspects of Sarkar’s political thought, including the influence of Hindu religion, disdain for humanism, and fascination for Nazism recur throughout the book. Sabastian goes beyond Sarkar’s much-reviled booklet on The Hitler State to examine this polymath intellectual’s view of popular sovereignty as well as his concern with eugenic concepts like purity, miscegenation, and myths of blood. However, Sarkar, whom Sabastian compares with the pro-Nazi jurist Carl Schmitt, was not just a theorist of fascism but an active propagandist of Nazi tenets. He disseminated pro-Nazi propaganda, often infused with Hindu notions, to an elite Indian audience at the Bengali German Knowledge Society, which he founded in Calcutta in 1933.
Savarkar wanted to induce a ‘warlike ethos’ among the Hindu male youth
The second chapter, “Savarkar’s Miscegenous Race,” throws new light on aspects of the ideological repertoire of Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, the ideological founder of Hindu nationalism. Sarvarkar’s project, as Sabastian ably demonstrates, was to induce a warlike ethos among the Hindu male youth, so that they could vanquish (eliminate) men from other religions (primarily Muslims) and marry, if necessary by force, women from the defeated communities. The women would then be converted to Hinduism and induced to produce many Hindu offspring. The aim was an “erasure of the Muslim as a potential site of sovereignty”.
The third chapter, titled “The Nazi Volk against Kaste,” is a significant scholarly intervention. Contrary to the widespread view that the Nazis approved of the caste system, which they interpreted as a form of racial segregation, Sabastian maintains that members of the Nazi ruling coterie like Hitler, Himmler and Rosenberg publicly proclaimed that the caste system was an obstacle to forming a Volksgemeinschaft or a racially homogeneous national community, a much vaunted Nazi idea.
This chapter posits that though 19th-century European intellectuals like Arthur Gobineau praised the inequalities of caste, which they defined as an amalgamation of race and class (p. 94), during the First World War the fraternity of soldiers purged of caste became “the first building block” of the Nazi ideal of Volksgemeinschaft. However, the chapter remains silent on the fact that around 1916, aspersions about the supposedly inadequate contribution of the Jews to the war effort became pervasive in the German Army and beyond, thus excluding Jews from any prospective German Volksgemeinschaft.

Luna Sabastian’s book Fascism in India: Race, Caste, and Hindutva (Harvard University Press, September 2025) takes a refreshingly novel approach.
Drawing on impressive research, Sabastian provides engrossing details, e.g., Hitler publicly employed the word Kaste about two dozen times and always in a negative way (p. 98), and that Kaste was not a staple of Himmler’s vocabulary. Nevertheless, Sabastian has not adequately emphasised that the conflation of caste and race in the context of India remained in vogue among influential German scholars. Sabastian has noted that the identification of caste with race played an important role in the scholarship of Hans Günther (p. 107).
An examination of comparable works by scholars like Eugen Fischer, who provided academic legitimacy to Nazi eugenics, would have revealed the prevalence of similar racialized ideas. These racist views were bequeathed by Fischer to his Indian students, P.C. Biswas and Iravati Karve, who, as leading anthropologists, deployed them in colonial and post-colonial India.
Himmler thought being Kshatriya would be a “salvation”
This chapter also mentions that Himmler thought being Kshatriya would be a “salvation” and his entourage produced a “Nazified, Aryan Gita”. The latter presumably refers to the interpretation of the Gita by the Indologist Jakob Wilhelm Hauer, a member of the Nazi Party and a high-ranking SS officer. Hauer glorified the ancient Hindu text not just as a manifestation of “Indo-Aryan metaphysics of war and deed.” He also celebrated its purported portrayal of the Kshatriyas preserving the purity of their caste and, with it, their Aryan blood, as well as the warning issued by the god Krishna against the mixing of the four castes.
Chapter four, titled “The Hindu Crown,” delineates Savarkar’s attempts at “reconstituting India’s imperial centre as a Hindu one” and endowing it with sovereignty, which Savarkar located in the medieval Maratha polity and in the Hindu kingdom of Nepal. This chapter provides fascinating glimpses of the connections between the Hindu Mahasabha, the ideological forerunner of the BJP, and the king of Nepal on the eve of India’s independence. This chapter also contains an enriching discussion of Savarkar’s famous work, The Indian War of Independence (1909). A minor drawback here is that Sabastian uncritically reiterates Savarkar’s claim that in the Puranas, Indrajit’s sacrifice earned him “the celestial boon” of an invincible chariot.
This incident is actually from the epic Ramayana, in which prince Indrajit did not receive the chariot since he could not complete the sacrifice (yajna). The irony of Savarkar being insufficiently familiar with the Ramayana, whose hero Rama has become a potent political symbol for contemporary Hindu Nationalists, should not be missed.
The fifth chapter, “After the Dualism of Pakistan” concerns the immediate post-independence and post-partition years. It traces Hindu nationalism’s evolution from Savarkar’s concepts of miscegenation and war to Dindayal Upadhyaya’s attempts to render a more humane face to Hindu Nationalism through his ideal of Integral Humanism. The latter, as this chapter brilliantly establishes, co-opted different elements of Hindu religion and called for an integrated homogeneous Indian (Hindu) society in which the Muslim Other would cease to exist.
In the epilogue, Sabastian points out that despite exhibiting many features of Upadhayaya’s thought, Hindutva has not relinquished Savarkar’s ideal of violence and of subsuming the Other. Violence against Muslims has indeed become commonplace in India, but whether the Hindu Nationalists still wish to forcibly absorb the Muslims is debatable. Recent governmental measures like changing the citizenship laws, revising electoral rolls and opening ‘transit camps’ indicate an attempt to disenfranchise and, if possible, dispense with them. In this regard, Hindu nationalist politics reverberates in the anti-migrant slogan of “remigration” raised recently by a resurgent brand of far-right politics in Germany.
Notwithstanding certain imperfections, Luna Sabastian’s book provides important insights into the complex history of a transnational ideology whose legacy continues to haunt India, Germany and the world.
Reference Link:- https://thewire.in/books/an-examination-of-fascist-ideas-in-india-and-in-nazi-germany






